You can use your existing Medical Independent, MediLearning or PharmacistCPD account to log in. is Ireland's only investigative medical news website for doctors, healthcare professionals and anyone with an interest in health issues.

Established in 2010, along with its sister publication The Medical Independent, our stated aim is to investigate and analyse the major issues affecting healthcare and the medical profession in Ireland. The Medical Independent has won a number of awards for its investigative journalism, and its stories are frequently picked up by national digital, broadcast and print media. The Medical Independent is published by GreenCross Publishing.

Address: Top Floor, 111 Rathmines Road Lr, Dublin 6

Tel: 353 (01) 441 0024

GreenCross Publishing is owned by Graham Cooke.

The benefits of registering: only registered users:
  • receive the ecCopy two days prior to the printed edition.
  • have automatic access to our free CPD sites.
  • can partake in our online MCQs.
  • can enter our online sports quiz.

Sign up now for ease of access to The Medical Independent, Ireland’s most frequently published medical newspaper, delivering award-winning news and investigative reporting.

Download the new Mindo app for both IOS & Android.

  • Get notified when a story goes live
  • Access Premium Content
  • Read Offline
[the_ad_placement id="main-ldb-public"]
[the_ad_placement id="main-ldb-mobile-public"]

Myths and medicine

By Dermot - 24th Oct 2016 | 8 views

<p class=”p1″><span class=”s1″>In a</span> piece for <em>The Liberal</em> (14 May, 2007), Marina Warner reminds us that the writer Jorge Luis Borges (1899-1986) “liked myth because he believed in the principle of ‘reasoned imagination’: knowing old stories, and retrieving them, reworking them, brought about illumination in a different way from rational inquiry”.

<p class=”p3″><span class=”s1″>To the extent that the ‘art’ of medicine attempts to negotiate the fuzzy interface between science and human sensibility, myths help enrich our understanding of the human condition. Which is fine: Myths offer a bubble bath for the soul, where the stubborn grime of reality can be – temporarily – washed off. But when imagination masquerades as reason it is time for myths to be exploded because their perpetuation can destroy lives. Thus, in their analysis of the Ryan Report (2009) in to child abuse in Irish care institutions, Powell <em>et al</em>, in the <em>British Journal of Social Work</em> (2013, 43: 7−23) adduce evidence showing how “discursive tricks” allowed Irish civil society to blame victims, not perpetrators: “The ‘charity myth’ that led to the mass incarceration of deprived children was perhaps the ultimate discursive trick in terms of renaming the child victim as the culpable party.”</span>

<blockquote> <p class=”p1″>…although the medical myth train appears to be ‘ram-packed’, there are in fact spare seats available 

</blockquote> <p class=”p3″><span class=”s1″>In the preface to his <em>The Myth of the Mahatma: Gandhi, the British and the Raj</em> (1986), Michael Edwardes warns that ignorance of the facts behind myths can become a menace. This applies not only to those who happily ignore the fact that Richard Attenborough’s film <em>Gandhi</em> (1982), for example, distorts the truth on a Wagnerian scale, but also to those who perpetuate medical myths. Given their propensity to strengthen on re-telling, it seems apt to borrow a recent Jeremy Corbyn phrase and suggest that although the medical myth train appears to be “ram-packed”, there are in fact spare seats available. </span>

<p class=”p3″><span class=”s1″>For example, Schulz <em>et al</em> in the <em>Journal of Emergency Medicine</em> (2016, 51: 25−30) consider the ‘Top Ten Myths Regarding the Diagnosis and Treatment of Urinary Tract Infections,’ with myth number two, for example, stating that if bacteria are present in urine, “my patient has a UTI”. But the authors assert that bacteria in the urine, as detected by microscopy or following positive culture in the absence of UTI symptoms, do not indicate a UTI “due to the possibility of contamination and asymptomatic bacteriuria”.</span>

<p class=”p3″><span class=”s1″>Creed is busy ‘Exploding myths about medically unexplained symptoms’, dismissing, inter alia, in the <em>Journal of Psychosomatic Research</em> (2016, 85: 91−93) the myth that “medically unexplained symptoms indicate an underlying psychiatric disorder”. This arose partly because of the creation of the diagnosis of undifferentiated somatoform disorder and its inclusion in the <em>Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM)</em>, 4th Edition… now abandoned in <em>DSM-5</em>.</span>

<p class=”p3″><span class=”s1″>Staying with mental disorders, in his review of Ian White’s <em>Beating Depression the Drug Free Way: Getting Better by Breaking the Myths</em> (2011), Winking, writing in <em>Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry</em> (2012, 14: 78−79), agrees with White that declaring depression to be a disease does not make it one and that buying “into the myth of depression as a disease has some very negative and sometimes dangerous consequences … [making one] prone to taking pills to cure this mythical ‘disease’ perhaps forever and to physical and neurological detriment”.</span>

<p class=”p3″><span class=”s1″>And it was disquieting to learn that “police, prosecutors, clergy, medical providers, and therapists of both sexes have been known to endorse rape myths”. This is noted by Carr <em>et al</em>, whose ‘Debunking Three Rape Myths’ in the <em>Journal of Forensic Nursing</em> (2014, 10: 217−225) reports that, contrary to the myths endorsed by some of those in positions of power and trust, following sexual assaults women take variable amounts of time to present for emergency treatment; they only rarely experience moderate/severe physical or ano-genital injury; and do not typically display strong physical resistance against their attacker during at least part of the assault. </span>

<p class=”p3″><span class=”s1″>Finally, I was surprised to discover in <em>Nature</em> (2013, 502: 32-33) that one of the most enduring stories in medical microbiology is false. In ‘Great Myths Die Hard’, Dufour and Carroll dismantle the myth surrounding Joseph Meister’s death. In 1885, nine-year-old Joseph was bitten by a rabid dog; he was taken to see Louis Pasteur at his eponymous Institute in Paris; and he became the first human to be treated and saved by a rabies vaccine. In June 1940 Meister was working as a gatekeeper at the Pasteur Institute, and it is popularly recounted that when German forces demanded access to Pasteur’s tomb, 64-year-old Joseph refused to comply and shot himself. </span>

<p class=”p3″><span class=”s1″>However, the authors show that archive material in the Pasteur Institute, plus testimony from Meister’s granddaughter, reveal a different story. Meister had sent his wife and children from Paris ahead of the advancing Germans, but he believed that they had perished as a result of enemy bombing. Consumed with guilt at having sent them away, Meister used a gas stove to end his life. In a tragic irony, his family returned safely to Paris on the same day.</span>

<p class=”p3″><span class=”s1″>It seems that whether beard-twirling intellectuals or earnest, evidence-based zealots, none of us is immune to the lure of the myth. Our challenge is to recognise myths for what they are … and dispel them.</span>

Leave a Reply

[the_ad_placement id="main-ldb-public-2"]
[the_ad_placement id="main-ldb-mobile-public-2"]
Latest Issue
The Medical Independent – 24 June 2021

You need to be logged in to access this content. Please login or sign up using the links below.

[the_ad_placement id="main-mpu-public"]
Most Read
[the_ad_placement id="main-ldb-public-2"]
[the_ad_placement id="main-ldb-mobile-public-2"]